No. 011 TechnologyCivilizationSingularity

Kosher Agents: Shabbat in an Age of Machines That Never Stop

Our machines work around the clock and our agents never sleep, but my orthodox friends wonder if they can leave their agents working during the day the Torah says even God was refreshed by resting.

Published
Reading
4 min
Sources
4

The defining feature of our agents is not that they are smart, but that they do not stop: a model answers at three in the morning as well as at noon. An agent can be told to keep working through the night, and it will. The ideal of the moment is a loop that runs forever, improving itself on every turn.

So when my friend Jack asked me if they could use leave their agents running, I knew I had to go down the rabbit hole. A very, very important disclaimer is that, while I am a Gemara/Kabbalah enjoyer, I am far from religious. Curiously enough, there was one tool that blending Judaism and Technology that could help me distill this: the one and only Sefaria MCP, developed by the amazing team at Sefaria.org.

Judaism, as always, has rabbis scurrying in Yeshivas discussing whether leaving the agent running is akin to leaving the lights on before Shabbat. However, there appears to be a protocol for exactly this situation. It's very old and very strict, and it says: once every seven days, all creative work stops.

What counts as work

The Mishnah lists the work forbidden on Shabbat. There are 39 primary categories ("forty-less-one") and the list is surprisingly concrete: sowing, plowing, reaping, grinding, baking, shearing, spinning, weaving, tying, building, kindling a fire. And, in the middle of the list, "one who writes two letters and one who erases in order to write two letters."

The Talmud explains where the list comes from. The forbidden labors "correspond to the labors performed in the Tabernacle." Whatever work the Israelites did to build the sanctuary in the desert, that is the work that stops on the seventh day.

The work that Shabbat suspends is not idle or sinful work, but the most valuable work there is: the construction of God's own house. The point is not that making things is bad, the point is that even the holiest making has to pause.

Note that writing is on the list. Two letters is enough to count.

God was refreshed

The verse that grounds all of this is in Exodus 31. Shabbat is "a sign for all time," because "in six days GOD made heaven and earth, [before] ceasing from work and being refreshed on the seventh day."

The Hebrew word for "being refreshed" is vayinafash. Its root is nefesh, soul. A very literal reading would say that on the seventh day God was re-souled.

This is the deepest claim in the text. Rest is not the absence of work, a battery recharging so the machine can run again on Sunday. Rest is where the soul comes back. Six days of making produce a world. The seventh day is what makes the maker more than a maker.

Even the dead rest

There is a strange and lovely story in Sanhedrin. A Roman governor, Turnus Rufus, challenges Rabbi Akiva: what makes this day different from any other? And how do you even know which day is Shabbat? Rabbi Akiva gives a few proofs: The Sabbatyon, which rages all week, is calm on Shabbat. A necromancer can prove it, because the dead do not rise on Shabbat. (Incidentally, he tells the governor with some cruelty, "the grave of your own father does not emit smoke on Shabbat, although it smokes all week.")

The imagery is wild, but the idea is clear. Shabbat is not only a human custom. It is built into the structure of the world. Rivers stop. Sorcery stops. Even punishment stops. Everything that runs, rests.

A rhythm for the machine age

I do not think the lesson is that our machines should take Saturdays off, although the idea has some charm—at least for me, who works pretty much 24/7. The lesson is about us, and about the shape of a civilization that has learned to run without stopping.

A system that never pauses has no point at which to ask what it is for. Shabbat creates that point by force. It does not depend on anyone feeling tired or deciding they have done enough. It arrives every seven days whether the work is finished or not, and the work is never finished. That is what makes it a protocol and not a preference.

As we build tools that can work forever, the question is whether we will keep any part of life that does not. The Torah's answer is that the world was not finished on the sixth day, with everything made. It was finished on the seventh, when the making stopped and the maker was refreshed.

Contents

    Theme

    Text size